Anxiety Therapy in Indianapolis
You know you’re overthinking. You just can’t seem to stop.
Schedule a free 15-minute consultationReplaying conversations. Preparing for the worst. Finally sitting down to relax while your brain revisits everything you said on Tuesday.
It’s exhausting. Together, we’ll work on understanding what keeps the anxiety going and practicing ways to respond differently, so worry can take up less of your day.
- In person in Indianapolis
- Online in Indiana
- Online in Florida
Anxiety can take up a surprising amount of room in your life.
You may be functioning just fine on the outside.
You go to work. You answer the texts. You take care of people. You make the lists. You think through every possible scenario, sometimes twice. And somehow your brain is still saying: Yes, but have we considered everything that could go wrong?
Anxiety can look like panic and obvious fear. It can also look like overthinking, perfectionism, irritability, trouble sleeping, replaying conversations, constantly preparing, needing reassurance, avoiding things, or simply never feeling fully settled.
We help you understand what is keeping the anxiety going, practice responding differently, and work toward a life that isn’t organized around fear.
You don’t need to be falling apart before you ask for help, and you don’t need to know what you’re anxious about before you schedule. Figuring that out is part of the work.
Not every day looks like this, and you may recognize only one or two.
- MorningWaking up already braced for something, before the day has given you a reason.
- Work and homeOverpreparing, double-checking, and taking care of everyone, while worrying that one mistake will change how people see you.
- EveningReplaying a conversation after everyone else has moved on, or rewriting a text until every version sounds wrong.
- NightYou finally have time to rest. Apparently, your brain has other plans, and it has scheduled a staff meeting for 2:00 a.m.
Anxiety can be obvious. It can also be remarkably sneaky.
Sometimes your heart races, your chest tightens, and your mind immediately begins searching for an escape route. Other times, you look completely competent from the outside while internally running seventeen different contingency plans.
You might even wonder whether you “qualify” as anxious because you’re still getting things done. You do. Anxiety is not measured by how impressive you look while experiencing it.
In your mind
- Constant worry, or a mind that rarely shuts off
- Racing thoughts and chronic overthinking
- Replaying conversations and second-guessing what you said
- Trouble concentrating or making decisions
- Intrusive thoughts that are hard to let go of
- Trying to create certainty where certainty isn’t available
In your body
- Feeling restless, tense, keyed up, or on edge
- A racing heart, dizziness, nausea, or sweating
- Waking with dread, or lying awake despite exhaustion
- Panic attacks or sudden waves of intense fear
- Feeling worn out from being “on” all the time
In what you do
- Avoiding people, places, activities, travel, or driving
- Perfectionism, and mistakes that feel unusually dangerous
- Overpreparing and checking that everything is okay
- Canceling plans you actually wanted to keep
- Putting off decisions or appointments
With the people you love
- Needing reassurance that never quite sticks
- Being short or irritable when you’re stretched thin
- Withdrawing, or being there but not fully present
- Worrying excessively about what other people think

When your body sounds the alarm
Panic and intense anxiety can feel like something is physically wrong: a pounding heart, dizziness, tightness in the chest, trouble catching your breath, the room feeling unreal. It is frightening, and it is also something therapy treats.
We help you understand what your body is doing, practice responding to it differently, and become less afraid of the sensations themselves. New or worrying symptoms still deserve a medical check, and we will always encourage one when it makes sense. You do not need to match every item above, and you do not need to wait until anxiety disrupts your life. See the types of anxiety we treat.
What kind of anxiety are you dealing with?
There is no single anxiety personality. Two people can both struggle with anxiety and look completely different. Understanding your particular pattern helps us figure out what kind of help is most likely to work.
Generalized anxiety and chronic worry
Your mind moves quickly from one concern to another. Work. Money. Your kids. Your health. Your relationship. Something you said Tuesday. Something that might happen six months from now.
You may know that worrying isn’t solving the problem. Your brain remains unconvinced. Therapy can help you recognize worry patterns, get more comfortable with uncertainty, and stop treating every anxious thought as something that needs immediate investigation.
Panic attacks and fear of panic
Your heart races, your breathing changes, and you feel dizzy, disconnected, or convinced something terrible is happening. Then another problem develops:
You start monitoring your body, avoiding certain places, making sure you can leave. Therapy can help interrupt that cycle and rebuild trust in your body.
Social anxiety
It isn’t necessarily shyness. It can be spending an enormous amount of time wondering how you came across.
You may avoid social events, speaking up, dating, networking, or conflict. Therapy can help you spend less energy monitoring yourself and more energy actually taking part.
High-functioning anxiety and perfectionism
Some anxious people are extremely productive. Actually, anxiety may be one of the reasons. You prepare. Overprepare. Double-check. Anticipate problems. Try not to disappoint anyone. And you accomplish quite a bit while privately feeling slightly behind.
It’s hard to recognize because many of the behaviors get rewarded. Therapy isn’t about making you care less or lowering every standard you have. It’s about figuring out when conscientiousness has quietly become fear.
Anxiety connected to trauma
Sometimes anxiety isn’t primarily about what is happening now. Your nervous system learned from something that happened before. You may understand logically that you are safe while your body keeps reacting as though the danger is still present.
When anxiety is tied to trauma, painful experiences, or persistent triggers, trauma-focused therapy and EMDR therapy may be part of the plan. Jenny also offers EMDR intensives.
Anxiety therapy should involve more than telling you to breathe.
Breathing can be useful. We are fans of oxygen. But if deep breathing had completely solved your anxiety, you probably wouldn’t be reading a therapist’s website at 11:47 p.m.
Good treatment starts with understanding your particular anxiety cycle, and then changing the part of it you can change.
How anxiety keeps itself going
Most anxiety follows a loop like this one. Therapy works on the links you can change.
1. A trigger
A text, a deadline, a sensation, a silence
2. A thought
“What if this goes wrong?”
3. A body response
Tight chest, racing heart, jittery stomach
4. What you do
Avoid, check, overprepare, seek reassurance
5. Short relief
You feel calmer, for now
Relief teaches your brain that the alarm was right, so the next trigger fires faster. Sometimes the strategy you use to control anxiety is accidentally helping keep it alive.
Notice the pattern
We map your triggers, thoughts, body responses, and what you do next. Cognitive and behavioral strategies help you respond to anxious thoughts differently. The goal isn’t to convince yourself that nothing bad will ever happen. It’s learning that every anxious thought does not automatically deserve the role of Chief Executive Officer.
Make life bigger
Anxiety often grows when life gets smaller. When it fits, we help you approach what you’ve been avoiding in small, planned steps that you agree to in advance. The aim is for your nervous system to learn that discomfort and danger are not always the same thing.
Live with some unknowns
A surprising amount of anxiety is an attempt to answer a question that can’t be answered with certainty. We practice getting better at saying: I don’t know exactly what will happen, and I can handle not knowing.
Understand your body
Anxiety isn’t happening only in your thoughts. We may use grounding, mindfulness, body awareness, and breathing to help you recognize physical anxiety and respond to it without assuming something terrible is happening.
Address the past
When anxiety is connected to earlier experiences, triggers, or memories that still feel unusually present, EMDR therapy may be added. Not sure whether it fits? Read 7 questions to ask before starting EMDR.
Change what happens outside the room
The goal isn’t to become excellent at discussing anxiety with your therapist. Between sessions you practice, notice what happened, and bring it back. If a tool isn’t helping, tell us, and we’ll change it instead of repeating it.

A plan you can see
Your treatment plan is written down in plain language: what has been showing up, what you want to change, the skills you will practice, and how we will check progress. It is not a form that disappears into a file. You can ask to see it, question it, and change it with us as your life changes.
Your therapist will go over how it looks for you. Ask us how it works on a free call.
Major health sources, such as the National Institute of Mental Health, describe psychotherapy, medication, or both as treatment options for anxiety disorders, and name cognitive behavioral therapy and acceptance and commitment therapy among the therapy approaches. Your therapist will explain which approaches they use and why.
What getting started looks like
You don’t need a polished explanation. “I’ve been feeling anxious and I’m tired of it” is a complete sentence.
A free 15-minute call
We talk about what’s been going on, answer practical questions about fees, online sessions, and scheduling, and see whether we’re a good fit. You choose Jenny or Jill, or tell us you aren’t sure and we’ll help you decide.
Your first session
We ask what a typical week looks like, how you’re sleeping, and what you’ve already tried. You can bring notes, pause whenever you need to, or say “I’m blanking.” That’s allowed, and we’ll help the conversation get started.
A plan that fits you
Together we set goals, choose what to practice, and check regularly whether life is changing. If something isn’t helping, we adjust the plan. We will not just keep handing you the same suggestion.
Not sure whether your symptoms are physical, emotional, or both? We’ll ask, and we’ll encourage a medical check when it makes sense.
What can anxiety treatment help you do?
Anxiety treatment isn’t about eliminating every nervous thought. Some anxiety is part of being human. We’re aiming for something more realistic, and considerably more useful. Over time, you may begin to notice that you:
- Catch an anxiety spiral before you’ve devoted three hours to it
- Recover more quickly when something triggers you
- Need less reassurance, and avoid fewer things
- Sleep better because bedtime stops being prime-time worry hour
- Handle hard conversations without rehearsing every version
- Recognize physical anxiety without assuming something terrible is happening
- Make decisions without requiring absolute certainty
- Spend less time managing anxiety and more time living
These are examples of goals we might work toward together, not promised outcomes.
We set specific goals with you at the start, check in on them regularly, and talk plainly about what is and isn’t changing. You can tell us at any point that something isn’t working.
Anxiety therapy for adults, young adults, and teens
Anxiety doesn’t belong to one age group. Sometimes it’s the main problem, and sometimes it overlaps with depression, ADHD, trauma, grief, relationship problems, sleep difficulties, burnout, or a major life change. Part of good therapy is figuring out what you’re actually treating.
Adults
Work, relationships, parenting, health concerns, burnout, changing bodies, aging parents, major transitions. You may be doing all of it competently while your brain stays convinced you need to anticipate every possible problem.
Young adults
College, careers, money, relationships, independence, identity, and the pressure to know exactly what you’re doing before you’ve had time to figure it out. Anxiety at this stage gets exhausting quickly.
Teens, with Jenny
School pressure, friendships, social anxiety, performance anxiety, family stress, ADHD, and perfectionism can all feed anxiety. Jenny works with teens ages 15 and up. Learn about teen therapy →
Meet Jenny and Jill.
Therapy for anxiety shouldn’t feel like someone reading coping strategies off a laminated handout. Both of us are active, curious, collaborative, and willing to tell you what we’re noticing. You can ask questions, disagree, be candid, and tell us something isn’t helping. You don’t have to perform being “good at therapy.” You already have enough things to overthink.

Jenny Staats, LMSW
Warm, practical, and collaborative: less “try harder,” more “let’s figure out why this isn’t working.” Jenny works with teens (15 and up), young adults, and adults on anxiety, ADHD, depression, and trauma, and she is an EMDR therapist who also offers EMDR intensives.
- Anxiety
- ADHD
- EMDR
- Teens 15+

Jill Frame, LMFT, CST
Warm and direct. Jill works with adults on anxiety, trauma, grief, and the way anxiety shows up in relationships, including the reassurance-seeking, irritability, and withdrawal that can strain the people closest to you. The aim is to be more present with the people you love, with worry pulling your attention away less often. She is also an EMDR therapist.
- Anxiety
- Trauma + EMDR
- Relationships
Looking for insurance? Christie Jansing, LCSW, also treats anxiety, trauma, and depression. She accepts insurance and currently has a waitlist. Learn about Christie →
Anxiety counseling in Indianapolis, Indiana
We see clients in person throughout Indianapolis and surrounding communities, including Broad Ripple, Meridian-Kessler, Carmel, Fishers, Zionsville, Brownsburg, and Avon. Online therapy lets you meet from home when getting across town feels like one more thing you don’t need on your schedule.
Prefer in person?
High Thrive Counseling6229 Indianola Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46220
Our Broad Ripple office is convenient to Indianapolis and surrounding communities.
Questions about anxiety therapy
It’s normal to feel anxious about starting anxiety treatment. Here are the questions people ask most.
How do I know if I need therapy for anxiety?
You don’t need to wait until anxiety becomes unbearable. Consider talking with a therapist when worry, fear, panic, overthinking, avoidance, irritability, physical anxiety, or trouble relaxing is starting to affect your relationships, work, school, sleep, decisions, or ability to enjoy your life. Another perfectly legitimate reason: you’re tired of dealing with it.
Can therapy help if I’m still functioning but feel anxious all the time?
Yes, and it’s extremely common. You can have a successful career, keep your relationships going, and manage your responsibilities while spending an exhausting amount of energy worrying, preparing, and trying to control outcomes. Sometimes this is called high-functioning anxiety. How well you perform on the outside doesn’t tell us how much anxiety is costing you on the inside.
Why can’t I stop overthinking when I know it isn’t helping?
Because understanding a pattern and changing your response to it are two different skills. Many people already have plenty of insight. We work on the gap: what you practice when the loop starts, how you handle the urge to keep reviewing or checking, and how we’ll tell whether daily life is actually changing.
Can anxiety cause physical symptoms?
Yes. Anxiety activates the body’s stress response and can cause a racing heart, tight chest, muscle tension, dizziness, nausea, sweating, shaking, headaches, stomach trouble, shortness of breath, or feeling disconnected from your surroundings. New or concerning symptoms should be checked by a medical provider rather than assumed to be anxiety, and we’ll encourage that when it makes sense.
Can therapy help with panic attacks?
Yes. Therapy can help with panic attacks and with the fear of having more of them. Treatment often focuses on understanding the body’s alarm response, changing catastrophic interpretations of physical sensations, reducing avoidance, and becoming less afraid of anxiety itself.
What actually happens in anxiety therapy?
We identify a specific pattern, agree on goals, practice new responses, and review what happened between sessions. That might mean noticing a thought and responding to it differently, taking a small step toward something you’ve been avoiding, learning to tolerate not knowing, or working with the body’s stress response. See how the anxiety cycle works.
No polished explanation is required to start. You can bring notes, take a pause, or tell us you’re blanking. And if you’ve tried therapy before and it didn’t help, tell us what you tried. We’ll set specific goals and check whether the plan is helping, and if it isn’t, we change it.
What type of therapy is best for anxiety?
No single therapy is best for every person or every type of anxiety. Health sources such as the National Institute of Mental Health name cognitive behavioral therapy and acceptance and commitment therapy, often with behavioral and exposure-based work. When anxiety is connected to trauma, EMDR or other trauma-focused therapy may help. We’ll recommend an approach based on your symptoms, history, goals, and the patterns keeping the anxiety going.
Will I have to take medication?
No. Therapy and medication are separate options, and some people use both. Jenny and Jill don’t prescribe medication. If you’re curious about it, a primary care provider or psychiatric prescriber can talk it through with you, and with your permission we can coordinate with them. We won’t push you toward or away from medication.
How long does anxiety therapy take, and how will we know it’s helping?
It depends. Some people come in with a specific anxiety problem and make meaningful progress relatively quickly. Others are working with long-standing anxiety, trauma, ADHD, depression, or patterns that developed over many years. We’ll talk about how often to meet and set goals together, then review progress regularly and adjust. Our goal isn’t therapy forever. It’s useful therapy.
Can I meet online, and what does it cost?
Yes. Sessions are 55 minutes, in person in Broad Ripple or online for people located in Indiana or Florida. Jenny and Jill are out-of-network. We can provide a superbill for possible reimbursement, many people use HSA or FSA funds, and reimbursement depends on your plan. Christie accepts insurance and currently has a waitlist. See fees and insurance details.
If you’re in crisis or worried about your safety, call or text 988 (the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline) right away.
When anxiety and trauma overlap
If your anxiety seems tied to something that happened, these may help. Take what fits.
Grounding techniques for dissociation
Practical ways to come back to the present when anxiety or trauma pulls you out of it.
Read about grounding →Is EMDR right for me?
Seven questions to ask first, about memory, overwhelm, preparation, trust and timing.
Read the 7 questions →Emotional damage, numbing, and trauma
Why some people feel flat, on edge, or disconnected after a hard experience.
Read about numbing →Keep reading
Trauma and EMDR
You don’t have to wait until anxiety gets worse.
Maybe you’ve been living with anxiety for years. Maybe it suddenly got louder. Maybe nothing dramatic happened at all, and you’ve simply realized that spending this much of your life worried, braced, checking, planning, and replaying is exhausting.
That is enough reason to do something different.
Jenny or Jill can help you understand what’s happening, build a plan that fits you, and start changing the patterns that keep anxiety in charge.
Schedule a free 15-minute consultationIn person in Broad Ripple · Online in Indiana + Florida
